Reviewer Guidelines | World Journal of Clinical Images

Role of Reviewers

Peer reviewers are essential to maintaining the scientific accuracy, clinical relevance, and overall quality of the journal. Your feedback helps authors improve their work and assists editors in making informed publication decisions.

Review Process Overview

• Double-blind peer review system.
• Evaluate both clinical images and manuscript clarity.
• Submit reviews within 2 weeks (extensions can be requested).

Criteria for Evaluation

• Image Quality & Relevance
• Scientific Accuracy
• Clarity and Structure
• Novelty & Educational Value
• Ethical Compliance

Reviewer Responsibilities

• Provide constructive and respectful feedback.
• Highlight both strengths and weaknesses.
• Give clear recommendations: Accept, Minor/Major Revisions, Reject.
• Maintain confidentiality and integrity.

Confidentiality & Ethics

All content shared for review is confidential. Do not contact authors directly. Declare any conflicts of interest before accepting to review.

How to Submit Your Review

• Access the manuscript via the journal platform or email.
• Submit your review in two parts:
  • Comments to the Editor (confidential)
  • Comments to the Author (anonymous)
• Provide your recommendation.

Reviewer Recognition

• Certificates of Reviewing upon request.
• Annual recognition (with consent).
• Opportunity to join the Editorial Board.

Need Help?

Contact Us